Find the largest integer $n$ such that $n$ is divisible by all positive integers less than $\sqrt[3]{n}$.
Problem
Source: APMO 1998
Tags: number theory, least common multiple, floor function, induction
17.03.2006 21:10
It is equavalent to find largest m, suth that $\sum_{p-prime<m} [\frac{ln(m-1)}{ln(p)}]ln(p) <3ln(m).$ We have $2^2*3*5*7=420<8^3$ and $2^3*3*5*7=840>9^3,2^3*3^2*5*7=2520>10^3,\dots$. Therefore n=420.
17.03.2006 21:17
When have cube root of n less than or equal to 8, n is divisible by 420 (the lcm of 1,2,3,4,5,6,7). then largest n is 420, because 8^3 = 512. Now let's see what happens when the cube root is greater than or equal to 8.Have: n is divisible by lcm(1 through 8)=840. So, n =< 9^3 = 729 doesn't work. Then n is divisible by lcm(1-9) = 7560. n >= 19 ^ 3. but then, n is divisible by 11,13,17 so lcm(1-cube root of n) gets huge, nad from there it's pretty easy to prove that n>= 19 doesn't work. So, it's 420
28.04.2009 20:24
rem wrote: lcm(1-9) = 7560. It's 2520, not 7560. rem wrote: nad from there it's pretty easy to prove that n>= 19 doesn't work This is the only "complicated" part of the problem. Anyone can notice that lcm gets huge. The problem is actually asking you to prove that.
03.05.2009 11:01
For any integer n, select k s.t. $ k^3 \leq n < (k + 1)^3$ We have $ lcm(1,2,3,.....,k) \geq k(k - 1)(k - 2)(k - 3)/6 > (k + 1)^3 > n$ for $ k > 12$ Hence, $ n < 13^3 = 2197$ Then we easily see that the answer is 420 Im unable to understand your solution Rust. Could you please explain it ?
19.05.2012 10:12
First off, remark that for the region $7^3<n<8^3$, we have $\lfloor \sqrt[3]{n} \rfloor=7$ therefore we must have $\text{lcm}(1,2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7)|n$ giving us $420|n$ or therefore since $343<n<512$ we must have $n=420$. However, for the region $8^3<n<9^3$, we have $\lfloor \sqrt[3]{n} \rfloor=8$ therefore we must have $\text{lcm}(1,2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8)|n$ giving us $840|n$ however, $512<n<729$ giving us an obvious contradiction. From here, I am going to prove that $\text{lcm}(1,2, 3, \cdots n)>(n+1)^3$ for all $n\ge 9$ which in turn proves that looking in the region $n^3, (n+1)^3$, there are no solutions for all $n\ge 8$ (since we have already proven $8$ above) giving $\boxed{420}$ as our maximum. First off, remark that the maximum power of $2$ less than $n$ is at least $\frac{n}{2}$, for $3$ it is$\frac{n}{3}$, for $5$ it is $\frac{n}{5}$ and for $7$ it is at least $\frac{n}{7}$. From here, I will prove that the given equation works for $n=9$ through $13$ then explain why this completes our proof. For $n=9$, we get $3*840>10^3$ obviously true. For $n=10$, we get $3*840>11^3$ or $2520>1331$ again true. For $n=11$, we get $2520*11>12^3$ or $27720>12^3$ which is obviously true along with $27720>13^3$ and $27720>14^3$ since $27720>20^3=8000$. From here, remark that the maximum power of $11$ less than $11$ is at least $\frac{n}{11}$ and for $13$ it is $\frac{n}{13}$. Therefore, since we are going to take the product of all of these different factors in the lcm, we are going to assume the minimal case and get $\frac{n^6}{2*3*5*7*11*13}$ which we desire to have being greater than $(n+1)^3$. Taking the cube root of both sides, we get an equation approximately the same as $\frac{n^2}{32}>(n+1)$ or therefore $n\ge 34$. Therefore we need to prove that for $n=14\to 33$, we are going to have Since we have at least $\text{lcm}(1,2, 3, \cdots, n)=\text{lcm}(1,2,3,4,\cdots, 13)$ which we desire to prove is greater than $(n+1)^3$ for $n=33$ proving our maximum case and thus proving the cases for $n=14\to 33$ as well since we are only using $n=13$ in our $\text{lcm}$. Note that $\text{lcm}(1,2, 3, 4, \cdots, 13)\approx 71^3$ therefore it is obviously greater than $34^3$ and our proof is complete $\blacksquare$.
27.07.2014 18:12
Why????? First off, remark that the maximum power of 2 less than n is at least \frac{n}{2}, for 3 it is\frac{n}{3}, for 5 it is \frac{n}{5} and for 7 it is at least \frac{n}{7}
27.07.2014 18:17
Since chek for n=7 the maximum power of 2 is 4 isnt it?
27.07.2014 18:24
Also this one how do you get for all n>12 it holds? We have lcm(1,2,3,.....,k) \geq k(k - 1)(k - 2)(k - 3)/6 > (k + 1)^3 > n for k > 12 If you indut it tell how to induct that one
28.07.2014 15:31
Why????? First off, remark that the maximum power of $2$ less than $n $ is at least $\frac{n}{2}$, for $3 $ it is $\frac{n}{3}$ , for $ 5 $ it is $ \frac{n}{5} $and for $ 7 $ it is at least $\frac{n}{7}$
28.07.2014 16:08
nawaites wrote: Why????? First off, remark that the maximum power of 2 less than n is at least \frac{n}{2}, for 3 it is\frac{n}{3}, for 5 it is \frac{n}{5} and for 7 it is at least \frac{n}{7} nawaites wrote: Why????? First off, remark that the maximum power of $2$ less than $n $ is at least $\frac{n}{2}$, for $3 $ it is $\frac{n}{3}$ , for $ 5 $ it is $ \frac{n}{5} $and for $ 7 $ it is at least $\frac{n}{7}$ Huh! What's the need to double-post after just $\text{\LaTeX}\text{ifying}$ the previous post? You could have easily edited it there.
16.07.2016 10:30
Sorry to revive. Could some mathlinkers explain Rust's solution? How can it be related with logrithm? Thanks in advance.
16.07.2016 13:36
26.11.2016 19:08
Of course, the general problem can also be shown to possess finitely many solutions: shobber wrote: Find the largest integer $n$ such that $n$ is divisible by all positive integers less than $\sqrt[k]{n}$ Let $\text{lcm}(1,2,\dots,m)=\mathcal{L}(m)$. Let the primes less than or equal to $m$ be $2,3,\dots,p$. We have $$\frac{\mathcal{L}(m)}{m^k}=\frac{2^{\left\lfloor \log_2(m)\right\rfloor}3^{\left\lfloor \log_3(m)\right\rfloor}\cdots p^{\left\lfloor \log_p(m)\right\rfloor}}{m^k}\geq\frac{2^{\log_2(m)-1}3^{\log_3(m)-1}\cdots p^{\log_p(m)-1}}{m^k}=\frac{m^{\pi(m)-k}}{2\cdot3\cdots p}$$Since the right is strictly increasing except when $n$ is prime (in which case it remains constant), after a certain point we must have $\tfrac{\mathcal{L}(m)}{m^k}>1\implies \mathcal{L}(m)\nmid m^k$ $\Box$
08.04.2018 07:01
this qn is from SMO open 2007 q5 ans is 420. suppose $p_k$ is the largest prime divisor of $x$ and the $k$th prime we show $p_k\leq 7$ suppose $p_k\geq 11$ $p_{k+1}<2p_k<4p_{k-1}<8p_{k-2}$ by Bertrand's postulate $p_{k+1}^3 < 64 p_k p_{k-1} p_{k-2} \leq 2^3 3^2 p_{k-2} p_{k-1} p_k | lcm(1,...,y) |x$ where $y=\lfloor \sqrt[3]{x} \rfloor$ , the first ineq comes from bertrand's postulate and third relation (divides) comes from smallest two and largest three prime factors of lcm(1,...,y). so $p_{k+1} < \sqrt[3]{x}$ $p_{k+1}|x$ , contradicting the maximality of $p_k$ so $p_k\leq 7 \implies \sqrt[3]{x}<p_{k+1}\leq 11$ $x<11^3=1331$ and $420|x$ implies x=420,840,1260 but only 420 satisfies conditions i dont get @rust soln
08.04.2018 10:51
The problems is casework
05.04.2021 16:37
20.07.2022 23:15
The main idea is to bound $n$ above; notice that for the condition to be true, we need $$\text{lcm}(1, 2, 3, \cdots, n) < (n+1)^3.$$We may lower bound $$\text{lcm}(1, 2, 3, \cdots, n) \geq \frac{n(n-1)(n-2)(n-3)}6$$because at most one factor of 2 and one factor of 3 are shared among these numbers. Thus, we must have $$\frac{n(n-1)(n-2)(n-3)}6 < (n+1)^3 \iff n \leq 12,$$so conducting a manual case check reveals $\boxed{420}$ to be the maximum when $n=7$.