A plane cuts a right circular cone of volume $ V$ into two parts. The plane is tangent to the circumference of the base of the cone and passes through the midpoint of the altitude. Find the volume of the smaller part. Original formulation: A plane cuts a right circular cone into two parts. The plane is tangent to the circumference of the base of the cone and passes through the midpoint of the altitude. Find the ratio of the volume of the smaller part to the volume of the whole cone.
Problem
Source: IMO ShortList 1990, Problem 10 (ICE 2)
Tags: geometry, 3D geometry, ellipse, sphere, Volume, IMO Shortlist
04.11.2005 20:02
The plane cuts the conic surface in an ellipse with (unknown) semimajor and semiminor axes p, q. We have to calculate the ellipse area $S = \pi p q$ and the distance d of the cone apex A from the plane. Then the volume of the cone part containing the cone apex A will be $V_A = \frac{S d}{3}$. Let O be the center of the cone circular base with radius r, h = OA the cone height, M the midpoint of OA and B the tangency point of the cutting plane with the cone circular base. Put the xyz-coordinate origin at the center O of the cone base, the positive z-axis in the direction of the ray OA and negative y-axis in the direction the ray OB. This makes the x- axis parallel and the yz-plane perpendicular to the cutting plane. The conic surface cuts the yz-plane in 2 cone elements AB, AB', with the points B, B' on the y-axis, and the cutting plane cuts the yz-plane in the line BM. Let the line BM cut the line AB' at a point C. The segment $BC = a = 2p$ is the ellipse major axis and the ellipse focal points $F_1, F_2$ are on this segment. The ellipse focal points $F_1, F_2$ are the tangency points of 2 spheres inscribed in the conic surface with the cutting plane. These 2 spheres cut the yz-plane in the incircle (I) and excircle (E) of the triangle $\triangle ABC$ touching the side BC. Let N be the midpoint of the segment BC (the ellipse center). The distances of the tangency points from the ellipse center are $ep = NF_1 = NF_2$, where e < 1 is the ellipse excentricity. The semininor axis q is then given by Pythagorean theorem for the right angle triangle $\triangle F_1NQ$, where Q, Q' are the intersections of a line in the cutting plane through the ellipse center N perpendicular to the ellipse major axis BC. That's because $QF_1 + QF_2 = 2p$ for a point on the ellipse and $QF_1 = QF_2 = p$ because of symmetry. Hence, $q = \sqrt{QF_1^2 - NF_1^2} = \sqrt{p^2 - e^2p^2}$. Working in the yz-plane, the points A, B, B', M have the yz-coordinates A = (0, h), B = (-r, 0), B' = (r, 0), M = (0, h/2). The equations of the lines BM, AB' intersecting at the point C are $BM: \ \ \ \frac{2z}{h} - \frac{y}{r} = 1$ $AB': \ \ \ \frac{z}{h} + \frac{y}{r} = 1$ Solving, we get the coordinates of the point $C = \left(\frac{r}{3}, \frac{2h}{3}\right)$ and the distance BC $BC = \sqrt{(y_C - y_B)^2 + (z_C - z_B)^2} = \sqrt{\frac{16r^2}{9} + \frac{4h^2}{9}} = \frac 2 3 \sqrt{4r^2 + h^2}$ Thus the ellipse semimajor axis is equal to $p = \frac{BC}{2} = \frac{\sqrt{4r^2 + h^2}}{3}$. Labeling the sides of the triangle $\triangle ABC$ as a = BC, b = CA, c = AB and its semiperimeter s, the distance of the tangency point $F_1$ of the incircle (I) with the side BC from the vertex C is equal to $CF_1 = s - c$ and the distance of this tangency point from the midpoint N of the side BC is equal to $NF_1 = \frac a 2 - (s - c) = \frac{c - b}{2}$. Since $z_C = \frac{2h}{3} = \frac{2z_A}{3}$ and the z-axis bisects the angle $\angle B'AB \equiv \angle CAB$, it is clear that $b = CA = \frac{AB}{3} = \frac{\sqrt{r^2 + h^2}}{3}$ and $NF_1 = \frac{c - b}{2} = \frac{\sqrt{r^2 + h^2}}{3} = b$. The ellipse semiminor axis is then equal to $q = \sqrt{QF_1^2 - NF_1^2} = \sqrt{\frac{a^2}{4} - b^2} = \sqrt{\frac{4r^2 + h^2}{9} - \frac{r^2 + h^2}{9}} = \frac{r}{\sqrt 3}$ and the ellipse area is $S = \pi pq = \frac{\pi r \sqrt{4r^2 + h^2}}{3 \sqrt 3}$. The distance d of the cone apex A from the cutting plane is equal to the A-altitude AD of the triangle $\triangle ABC$. The altitude passes through the point A = (0, h) and has the slope $m_{AD} = -\frac{1}{m_{BM}} = -\frac{2r}{h}$, being perpendicular to the line $BC \equiv BM$. Hence, the altitude equation is $AD: \ \ \ z = -\frac{2r}{h}\ y + h$ Solving the equations of the lines BM, AD, we get the coordinates of their intersection $D = \left(\frac{rh^2}{4r^2 + h^2}, \frac{2r^2h}{4r^2 + h^2} + h\right)$ and the distance d = AD $d = AD = \sqrt{(y_D - y_A)^2 + (z_D - z_A)^2} = \frac{\sqrt{r^2h^4 + 4r^4h^2}}{4r^2 + h^2} = \frac{rh}{\sqrt{4r^2 + h^2}}$ As a result, the volume $V_A$ is equal to $V_A = \frac{S d}{3} = \frac 1 3 \cdot \frac{\pi r \sqrt{4r^2 + h^2}}{3 \sqrt 3} \cdot \frac{rh}{\sqrt{4r^2 + h^2}} = \frac{\pi r^2 h}{9 \sqrt 3}$. On the other hand, the volume of the entire cone is equal to $V = \frac{\pi r^2 h}{3}$, so that $\frac{V_A}{V} = \frac{1}{3\sqrt 3}$. Clearly, $V_A = \frac{V}{3 \sqrt 3} < \frac V 2$ is the smaller volume.
Attachments:
