Three distinct points $A$, $B$, and $C$ are fixed on a line in this order. Let $\Gamma$ be a circle passing through $A$ and $C$ whose center does not lie on the line $AC$. Denote by $P$ the intersection of the tangents to $\Gamma$ at $A$ and $C$. Suppose $\Gamma$ meets the segment $PB$ at $Q$. Prove that the intersection of the bisector of $\angle AQC$ and the line $AC$ does not depend on the choice of $\Gamma$.
It's indeed simple: In triangle $AQC$ $QB$ is the symmedian, so $\frac{BA}{BC}=\frac{QA^2}{QC^2}$ and it's fixed, so $\frac{QA}{QC}$ must also be fixed, and we're done.
Solution
Let $D=G \cap PQ$. Because $ADCQ$ is cyclic, we have the following.
\[\frac{AD}{CQ}=\frac{BD}{BC} \quad \textbf{and} \quad \frac{AB}{BD}=\frac{AQ}{CD}\]
Multiplying these yields the following.
\[\frac{AB}{BC}=\frac{AQ}{QC} \cdot \frac{AD}{CD} \quad (1)\]
Since $\triangle{ADP} \sim \triangle{QAP}$ and $\triangle{CDP} \sim \triangle{QCP}$, we also have the following.
\[\frac{AD}{AQ}=\frac{DP}{AP}=\frac{DP}{CP}=\frac{CD}{CQ}\]
Substitution into (1) yields that
\[\frac{AQ}{CQ}=\sqrt{\frac{AB}{BC}}\]
Let $X$ be the intersection of the bisector of $\angle{AQC}$ with $AC$. By the angle bisector theorem we have that
\[\frac{AX}{XC}=\frac{AQ}{CQ}=\sqrt{\frac{AB}{BC}}\]
Therefore the location of $X$ on segment $AC$, is dependent only on the location of $B$.
Let $X$ be the point of intersection of $AC$ and the angle bisector of $\angle AQC$, and let $R$ be the second intersection of $PQ$ and circle $G$. It suffices to prove that $\frac{AX}{CX}$ is constant.
Noting that quadrilateral $ARCQ$ is harmonic, $\frac{AX}{CX}=\frac{AQ}{CQ}=\frac{AR}{CR}=\sqrt{\frac{AQ\cdot AR}{CQ\cdot CR}}=\sqrt{\frac{[AQR]}{[CQR]}}=\sqrt{\frac{AB}{BC}}$, which is indeed constant. We are done. $\blacksquare$
The coordinate bash is not too bad if you're careful:
Let $A$ be at $(-1,0)$, $B$ be at $\left(\frac{1}{a},0\right)$, $C$ be at $(1,0)$, and the center $O$ of circle $G$ be at $\left(0,-\frac{1}{k}\right)$. WLOG, $a>1$ and $k>0$. (if $B$ lies at $(0,0)$, the problem is obvious.)
Now, it is immediately evident that $P$ lies at $(0,k)$.
The equation of line $PB$ is $y=-kax+k$.
The equation of $G$ is $x^2+\left(y+\frac{1}{k}\right)^2=\frac{1}{k^2}+1$ or $k^2x^2+(ky+1)^2=k^2+1$
So, their intersection occurs when:
$k^2x^2+(-k^2ax+k^2+1)^2=k^2+1$
$k^2(k^2a^2+1)x^2-2ak^2(k^2+1)x+k^2(k^2+1)=0$
We can divide by $k^2$ to get
$(k^2a^2+1)x^2-2a(k^2+1)x+(k^2+1)=0$ so we have
$x=\frac{a(k^2+1)-\sqrt{a^2(k^2+1)^2-(k^2+1)(k^2a^2+1)}}{(k^2a^2+1)}$ (we obviously take the lesser root here). Simplifying, we get
$x=\frac{a(k^2+1)-\sqrt{(k^2+1)(a^2-1)}}{(k^2a^2+1)}$
Then, the y-coordinate $y$ of $Q$ is just $y=-kax+k$.
We need $\frac{QA}{QC}$ to be constant, so we must show that
$\frac{(x+1)^2+y^2}{(x-1)^2+y^2}=1+\frac{4x}{(x-1)^2+y^2}$ does not depend on $k$.
As $1$ clearly does not depend on $k$, it is sufficient to show $\frac{4x}{(x-1)^2+y^2}$ does not.
For convenience, denote $k^2a^2+1=p, k^2+1=q, \sqrt{q(a^2-1)}=r, ak^2+1=s$.
Thus, $x=\frac{aq-r}{p}$.
$\frac{4x}{(x-1)^2+y^2}=\frac{4x}{(k^2a^2+1)x^2-2(ak^2+1)x+(k^2+1)}$
Subbing in $x$'s value:
$\frac{\frac{4(aq-r)}{p}}{p\frac{(aq-r)^2}{p^2}-2s\frac{aq-r}{p}+q}$
Cancelling out some $p$'s we get
$\frac{4(aq-r)}{(aq-r)^2-2s(aq-r)+pq}$
The denominator is $a^2q^2-2aqr+r^2-2saq+2rs+pq$
Subbing everything back in (except some $r$'s) we have the denominator to be:
$a^2(k^4+2k^2+1)-2a(k^2+1)r+(k^2+1)(a^2-1)-2a(k^2+1)(ak^2+1)+2r(ak^2+1)+(k^2a^2+1)(k^2+1)$
or
$-2r(a-1)+[a^2k^4+2a^2k^2+a^2-k^2+k^2a^2-1+a^2-2a^2k^4-2ak^2-2a^2k^2-2a+a^2k^4+a^2k^2+k^2+1]$
The stuff in the brackets is just:
$-2ak^2-2a+2a^2+2a^2k^2=2a(-k^2-1+a(k^2+1))=2a(k^2+1)(a-1)$
so the denominator is just $2aq(a-1)-2r(a-1)$
So all that's left to prove is that $\frac{4(aq-r)}{2(aq-r)(a-1)}=\frac{2}{a-1}$ is constant as $k$ varies, which is obviously true, as $a$ and $k$ are independent.
We see that $BQ$ is a symmedian. Let the angle-bisector intersect $AC$ at $K$. Then by Steiner's theorem $\frac{AB}{BC}=\frac{AQ^2}{AC^2}$, implying that $\frac{AQ}{QC}$ is fixed. But by the angle-bisector theroem, $\frac{AK}{KC}=\frac{AQ}{QC}$ and we have that $K$ is fixed.
Let the angle bisector of $\angle{AQC}$ intersect $AC$ at $X$. By the Angle Bisector Theorem, $AX/CX=AQ/CQ$. Then by Law of Sines:
\[ \frac{AQ}{CQ}=\frac{\frac{BQ\sin\angle{ABQ}}{\sin\angle{BAQ}}}{\frac{BQ\sin\angle{CBQ}}{\sin\angle{BCQ}}}=\frac{\sin\angle{BCQ}}{\sin\angle{BAQ}}=\frac{\sin\angle{QAP}}{\sin\angle{QCP}}\]
\[ =\frac{\frac{PQ\sin\angle{APB}}{AQ}}{\frac{PQ\sin\angle{CPB}}{CQ}}=\frac{CQ}{AQ}\cdot\frac{\sin\angle{APB}}{\sin\angle{CPB}}\]
\[ =\frac{CQ}{AQ}\cdot\frac{\frac{AB\sin\angle{ABP}}{AP}}{\frac{BC\sin\angle{CBP}}{CP}}=\frac{CQ}{AQ}\cdot\frac{AB}{BC}\]
so
\[ \left(\frac{AQ}{CQ}\right)^2=\frac{AB}{BC}.\]
It follows that $AX/CX=\sqrt{AB/BC}$, which is fixed, so the point $X$ is also fixed. //
Let the second intersection of the angle bisector with the circle be $R$.
Also , Let the intersection of $AC$ and the bisector be $Y$
Then from the similarity of $\Delta ARP$ and $\Delta QAP$ , we get , $\frac{AR}{RQ}=\frac{RP}{PA}$.
Similarly ,we get $\frac{RP}{PC}=\frac{RC}{QC}$.
So , $AQ/QC=AR/RC$ .
Now ,
$\frac{AB}{BC}=\frac{AR\sin{\angle{ARQ}}}{RC\sin{\angle{CRQ}}}$
So , $\frac{AQ}{QC}.\frac{AR}{RC}=\frac{AB}{BC}$
hence, $\frac{AY}{YC}=\frac{AQ}{QC}= (\frac{AB}{BC})^{1/2}$ , which is fixed. hence done
It suffices to show that $\dfrac{AQ}{QC}$ is fixed. Since $P$ lies on the $Q$-symmedian of $\triangle AQC,$ we must have $\dfrac{AQ}{QC}= \sqrt{\dfrac{AB}{BC}},$ which is fixed. $\blacksquare$
We first prove something.
Fact: If $N$ is the intersection of the $A$-symmedian with $BC$, then $\frac{\sin\angle CAN}{\sin\angle BAN}=\frac{AC}{AB}$.
Proof: Consider the median from $A$, $AM$, where $M$ is on $BC$. Then the Law of Sines yields that $\frac{\sin{\angle BAM}}{BM}=\frac{\sin{\angle AMB}}{AB}$ in $\Delta AMB$. Similarly, we can find that $\frac{\sin{\angle MAC}}{MC}=\frac{\sin{\angle CMA}}{AC}$ in $\Delta AMC$. Dividing the two, we have that $\frac{\sin{\angle BAM}}{\sin{\angle MAC}}=\frac{AC}{AB}$. If $N$ is the intersection of the $A$-symmedian with $BC$, we have $\frac{\sin\angle CAN}{\sin\angle BAN}=\frac{AC}{AB}$. $\Box$
By the Law of Sines in $\Delta ABQ$ and $\Delta BQC$, we find that $\frac{AB/\sin\angle AQB}{BC/\sin\angle BQC}=\frac{AQ/\sin\angle ABQ}{CQ/\sin\angle QBC}$. Since $\sin\angle ABQ=\sin\angle QBC$, our equation is $\frac{AB}{BC}\cdot\frac{\sin\angle BQC}{\sin\angle AQB}=\frac{AQ}{CQ}$. But $\frac{\sin\angle BQC}{\sin\angle AQB}=\frac{CQ}{AQ}$, so $\frac{AB}{BC}=\frac{AQ^2}{CQ^2}$. Hence $\frac{AQ}{CQ}$ is fixed, and we are done by the Angle Bisector Theorem. $\blacksquare$
FantasyLover wrote:
$\sqrt{\frac{AQ\cdot AR}{CQ\cdot CR}}=\sqrt{\frac{[AQR]}{[CQR]}}=\sqrt{\frac{AB}{BC}}$, which is indeed constant. We are done. $\blacksquare$
Why $\sqrt{\frac{[AQR]}{[CQR]}}$ gives us $\sqrt{\frac{AB}{BC}}$ ?
samirka259 wrote:
sjaelee wrote:
Then by Steiner's theorem $\frac{AB}{BC}=\frac{AQ^2}{AC^2}$, implying that $\frac{AQ}{QC}$ is fixed.
What does Steiner's theorem say ?
I didn't read proofs above, but if you are asking for Steiner's theorem, it may be the next theorem(I am too lazy to read the problem and solutions ): for $\triangle{ABC}$ and points $X$ and $Y$ that lies on side $AC$, $BX$ and $BY$ are symmetric wrt(I am not sure for this word, may be "about" suits more) angle bissector of $\angle{ABC}$ if and only if $\frac{AX*AY}{CX*CY}=\frac{AB^2}{CB^2}$. I am pretty sure, that I used this theorem when I was solving it on the training
I guess this was before symmedians were well known...
Let the bisector of angle $AQC$ intersect $AC$ at $T$. By the angle-bisector theorem, $\frac{AT}{CT}=\frac{AQ}{QC}$. By the Symmedian Lemma, we have that $BQ$ is the $Q$-symmedian of $AQC$. Thus, Steiner's theorem and our work before yields that $\frac{AT}{CT}=\frac{AQ}{QC}=\sqrt{\frac{AB}{BC}}$, which is fixed.
My solution was similar to those above:
Note that $QP$ is a symmedian of $\triangle QAC$, so $\frac{AB}{CB} = \frac{QA^2}{QC^2}$, so $\frac{QA}{QC}$ is fixed, and thus the point of intersection does not depend on $G$.
$BQ$ is a symmedian of $\triangle AQB$. Then let the intersection of $PQ$ and $AC$ be $G$ and $M$ be the midpoint of $AC$.
We get $\angle AQB = \angle MQC$ and $\angle AQM = \angle BQC$.
Firstly $\frac{AB}{MC}=\frac{|AQB|}{|MQC|}=\frac{0.5AQ \cdot BQ \sin{AQB}}{0.5MQ \cdot CQ \sin {MQC}} = \frac{AQ \cdot BQ}{MQ \cdot CQ}$
In a similar way $\frac{AM}{BC} = \frac{AQ \cdot MQ}{BQ \cdot CQ}$
Note the two above quantities are constant because $A,M,B,C$ are fixed.
Multiplying the two quantities, we get $\frac{AQ^2}{CQ^2}$ and therefore $\frac{AQ}{CQ}$ is constant.
Since $\frac{AG}{GC}=\frac{AQ}{CQ}$ by angle bisector theorem on $QG$, we get $G$ is fixed.
Huh? ISL G2?!!
darij grinberg wrote:
Three distinct points $A$, $B$, and $C$ are fixed on a line in this order. Let $\Gamma$ be a circle passing through $A$ and $C$ whose center does not lie on the line $AC$. Denote by $P$ the intersection of the tangents to $\Gamma$ at $A$ and $C$. Suppose $\Gamma$ meets the segment $PB$ at $Q$. Prove that the intersection of the bisector of $\angle AQC$ and the line $AC$ does not depend on the choice of $\Gamma$.
Let $T$ denote the intersection of the angle bisector of $\angle AQC$ with the fixed line $\overline{AC}$.
$ $
From the angle bisector theorem in $\triangle AQC$, we have that $\frac{AT}{CT} = \frac{ AQ}{CQ}$.
Also, since $\overline{QB}$ is the $Q-$ symmedian of $\triangle AQC$, by Steiner Ratio theorem we have that : $\frac{AB}{CB}= \left(\frac{AQ}{CQ}\right)^2$.
$ $
Therefore we have that $$\frac{AT}{CT} = \underbrace{\sqrt{\frac{AB}{CB}}}_{\text{Fixed}}$$So $T$ is fixed irrespective of choice of $\Gamma$.
Let $I$ be the intersection of the angle bisector with line $AC$ and let $X$ be the intersection of segment $PB$ with the circle. Then we have $\frac{AI}{IC} = \frac{AQ}{QC}$ by the Angle Bisector Theorem, and $AQ = \frac{PA \cdot AX}{PX}$ and $QC = \frac{PQ \cdot CX}{PX}$ and thus $\frac{AQ}{QC} = \frac{PA \cdot AX \cdot PC}{PX \cdot PQ \cdot CX} = \frac{PQ}{PA} \cdot \frac{AX}{PQ} \cdot \frac{PC}{CX} = \frac{AX}{CX}$. But by the Ratio Lemma we have $\frac{AX}{CX} \cdot \frac{\sin \angle AXB}{\sin \angle CXB} = \frac{AX}{CX} \cdot \frac{AQ}{QC} = \frac{AB}{BC}$. Thus, $\frac{AX}{CX} = \frac{\frac{AB}{BC}}{\frac{AQ}{QC}} = \frac{AQ}{QC}$, so $\frac{AB}{BC} = \left(\frac{AQ}{QC}\right)^2$. But this means that $\frac{AQ}{QC}$ is determined, and thus so is $\frac{AI}{IC}$ as desired.
Because $\overline{QBP}$ is the $Q$-Symmedian of $ACQ$, we have $$\frac{QA}{QC} = \sqrt{ \frac{BA}{BC} }$$which finishes via the Angle Bisector Theorem. $\blacksquare$
Remark: Because the center of $\Gamma$ doesn't lie on $\overline{ABC}$, we know $P$ isn't at infinity.
Nice problem and a good exercise in symmedians. We observe that $QP$ is a $Q-\text{symmedian}$ of $\triangle QBC$. Thus $\left(\frac{QA}{QC}\right)^2=\frac{AB}{AC} \implies \frac{QA}{QC}=\sqrt{\frac{AB}{AC}}$ so by angle bisector theorem the intersection of the bisector of $\angle AQC$ with $AC$ is a fixed point $X$ with $\frac{AX}{XC}=\sqrt{\frac{AB}{AC}}$.
Let $X$ be the desired point. Note that $QB$ is the Q-symmedian in $\triangle ACQ$. This means that the ratio $$QA/QC=\sqrt{AB/BC}$$does not depend on $\Gamma$. By the Angle Bisector Theorem, this also means that $AX/XC$ does not depend on $\Gamma$, so the location of $X$ does not depend on $\Gamma$, QED.
Is this the easiest isl?
Let the intersection be E. It's a well known property that QP is a symmedian of AQC, so then AB/BC=AQ^2/AC^2, and by angle bisector theorem the length AE/EC=AQ/AC is constant.
@above because symmedians can be constructed by drawing the equal tangents' intersection, QB==BP.
$\color{red} \boxed{\textbf{SOLUTION}}$
Let the angle bisector of $\angle AQC$ intersect $AC$ at $K$
$QB$ is the symmedian of $\triangle AQC$
So, $$\frac{AB}{BC}={\frac{AQ^2}{QC^2}} \implies \frac{AQ}{QC}=\sqrt{\frac{AB}{BC}} \implies \frac{AK}{KC}= \underbrace{\sqrt{\frac{AB}{BC}}}_{\text{Fixed}} \blacksquare$$
why is g1 and g2 both not hard symmedian problems
Clearly $QB$ is the $Q$-symmedian in $\triangle AQC$, so if we let $D$ be the foot of the $Q$-angle bisector in $\triangle AQC$, then
\[
\frac{AD}{DC} = \frac{AQ}{QC} = \sqrt{\frac{AB}{BC}}
\]which is fixed, so we're done. $\square$
We consider the converse: let $K,L$ lie on $\overline{AC}$ such that $(A,C;K,L)=-1$, and consider the circle $\Gamma$ with diameter $\overline{KL}$—some Apollonius circle. Let $Q$ be a variable point on $\Gamma$ and $P$ be the intersection of the tangents to $(ACQ)$ at $A$ and $C$. Then prove that $\overline{AC} \cap \overline{QP}:=X$ is fixed.
Clearly $X$ is the foot of the $Q$-symmedian. If $M$ is the midpoint of $\overline{AC}$, then $\overline{QK}$ and $\overline{QL}$ are the $Q$-angle bisectors in $\triangle QXM$, hence $(X,M;K,L)=-1$. Since $K,L,M$ are fixed independent of $Q$, it follows that $X$ is as well.
Returning to the main problem, as we vary $K$ and $L$ around $\overline{AC}$ such that $(A,C;K,L)$ holds, $X$ can achieve any point; in particular we can have $X=B$ (and $K$ lying inside segment $\overline{AC}$). Then as $Q$ varies for this fixed choice of $K,L$, $\Gamma$ can become any circle through $A$ and $C$. Hence in the original problem, the intersection of the $\angle AQC$-bisector and $\overline{AC}$ is fixed at $K$. $\blacksquare$
???
Let $D$ be the point where the angle bisector of $\angle AQC$ hits $\overline{AC}$. By construction, $QB$ is the $Q$-symmedian in $\triangle AQC$, so by the angle bisector theorem we have
$$\frac{AD}{DC} = \frac{AQ}{QC} = \sqrt{\frac{AB}{AC}},$$and $D$ is fixed, as needed.
Let $PB$ meets the circle $\Gamma$ at $D$ and $Q$, respectively. Then note that $ADCQ$ is harmonic (from the construction of the tangents).
Let the angle bisector of $\angle AQC$ meet $AC$ at a point $X$. Then note that
\[ \left( \frac{AX}{XC} \right)^2 = \left( \frac{AQ}{QC} \right)^2 = \frac{AB}{BC} \]where we use Angle Bisector theorem and the definition of a harmonic quadrilateral.
Thus, $X$ only depends on $A$, $B$, and $C$, as desired. $\blacksquare$
Let $R$ be the intersection point :
By isogonal ratios :
$\frac{AB}{AC} = \frac{AQ^2}{CQ^2}$
Using the angle bissector theorem :
$\frac{AQ^2}{CQ^2} = \frac{AR^2}{CR^2}$
Since $B$ is fixed, then $R$ is fixed, we are done.
Note that due to the Angle Bisector Theorem, the problem is equivalent to showing that $\frac{AQ}{QC}$ is fixed. But now notice that $BQ$ is the symmedian of $\Delta ABC$, so $\frac{AB}{BC} = \left( \frac{AQ}{QC} \right)^2 \implies \frac{AQ}{QC} = \sqrt{\left(\frac{AB}{BC}\right)}$, which is fixed. $\square$
Im liek 95% sure this is wrong
Observe that all points are determined by $A$, $B$, $C$, $P$. With $O$ the center of $\Gamma$ being defined as the harmonic conjugate of $P$ wrt to $AC$ on $(APC)$. And the arc midpoint of $AC$ on $(AQC)$ can be defined as the second intersection of $PO$ with $\Gamma$, and the intersection with the angle bisector can be defined as $QM \cap PB$. So we can affine transform the problem with cross ratios preserved. Notice we can affine transform so $P$ is any point on the perpendicular bisector of $AC$ and the cross ratio $(A,C; B, QM \cap AC)$ is fixed. Which implies the fixed-ness.
Ok now the symmedian B's foot is fixed (tangent going through A and C joined with B is basically the foot of symmedian , cite egmo or smth idk), the midpoint of AC is fixed so the foot of angle bisector is fixed QED