We distribute $n\ge1$ labelled balls among nine persons $A,B,C, \dots , I$. How many ways are there to do this so that $A$ gets the same number of balls as $B,C,D$ and $E$ together?
Problem
Source: Czech-Polish-Slovak 2005 Q4
Tags: floor function, algebra, polynomial, combinatorics unsolved, combinatorics
28.04.2013 11:12
here is an approach: We select $0\le 2k<n$ balls. Then choose $k$ balls among them for $A$. Rest of the $k$ balls may be distributed among $4$ people in $4^{k}$ ways. Remaining $n-2k$ balls may be distributed among rest $4$ people in $4^{n-2k}$ ways. Since, $k$ can range from $0$ to $\lfloor \frac{n}{2}\rfloor$, we get \[\sum_{k=0}^{\lfloor \frac{n}{2}\rfloor}\binom{n}{2k}\binom{2k}{k}4^{n-k}\]
28.04.2013 18:09
Ok, good; but can you show this is equal to the much simpler expression $2^n\binom{2n}{n}$?
28.04.2013 18:19
satori wrote: Rest of the $k$ balls may be distributed among $4$ people in $4^{k}$ ways. Remaining $n-2k$ balls may be distributed among rest $4$ people in $4^{n-2k}$ ways. What? If we have $B+C+D+E=k$, for nonnegative integers $B,C,D,E$, don't we have $\binom{k+3}{3}$ distributions?
28.04.2013 18:22
The balls and boxes are both labeled. (The boxes, because they have explicit names; the balls, because the problem says so.)
29.04.2013 20:27
Ah, missed "labeled balls". Thanks
29.04.2013 21:47
Might still be interesting in the case of unlabeled balls (just not the same problem ). (Of course, the same approach works; you get instead the sum $\sum_k \binom{k}{3} \binom{n - 2k + 3}{k}$, which simplifies as one of two seventh-degree polynomials in $n$ depending on whether $n$ is even or odd.) The problem of simplifying satori's answer to the expression I gave above is still open in this thread.
02.04.2020 21:50
Who can explain me, which is the correct solution for this nice Problem?