Let $ ABCD$ be a rhombus with $ \angle BAD = 60^{\circ}$. Points $ S$ and $ R$ are chosen inside the triangles $ ABD$ and $ DBC$, respectively, such that $ \angle SBR = \angle RDS = 60^{\circ}$. Prove that $ SR^2\geq AS\cdot CR$.
Problem. Let ABCD be a rhombus with < BAD = 60°. The points S and R lie inside the triangles ABD and DBC respectively such that < SBR = < RDS = 60°. Prove that $SR^2 \geq AS \cdot CR$.
Solution by Myth and me. We start with a simple lemma:
Lemma 1. For any angle t, we have $\sin\left( 60^{\circ}-t\right)+\sin\left( 60^{\circ}+t\right) \leq2\sin60^{\circ}$.
Proof. Using the addition formulas for sin, we get:
$\sin\left( 60^{\circ}-t\right) +\sin\left( 60^{\circ}+t\right)$
$=\left( \sin60^{\circ}\cos t-\cos60^{\circ}\sin t\right) +\left(\sin60^{\circ}\cos t+\cos60^{\circ}\sin t\right)$
$=2\sin60^{\circ}\cos t\leq2\sin60^{\circ}$ (since $\sin 60^{\circ}=\frac{\sqrt3}{2}\geq 0$ and $\cos t\leq 1$).
Now let's solve the problem:
Since the quadrilateral ABCD is a rhombus, we have DA = AB. Since we also have < BAD = 60°, the triangle BAD is equilateral; since a rhombus is symmetric with respect to each of its diagonals, the triangles BAD and BCD are congruent, so that the triangle BCD is also equilateral.
WLOG assume that $DS\leq DR$. Let X be a point on the ray DS such that DX = DR, and let Y be a point on the ray DR such that DY = DS. Then, since DX = DR and < RDX = 60° (this follows from < RDS = 60°), the triangle XDR is equilateral. Similarly, the triangle YDS is equilateral.
Since the triangle XDR is equilateral, we have < DXR = 60°. In other words, < SXR = 60°. The equilateral triangle YDS yields < DYS = 60°, so that < RYS = 180° - < DYS = 180° - 60° = 180° - < SXR. This implies that the quadrilateral RYSX is cyclic. In other words, the points R, Y, S and X lie on one circle. The point B also lies on this circle, since < SBR = 60° and < SXR = 60° imply < SBR = < SXR. Hence, all five points R, Y, S, X and B lie on one circle. Let r be the radius of this circle. Then, by the fact that the length of a chord in a circle equals the double circumradius times the sine of the chordal angle of this chord, we have $SR=2r\sin\measuredangle SBR$, $BX=2r\sin\measuredangle BSX$ and $BY=2r\sin\measuredangle BSY$.
Since the triangle YDS is equilateral, we have < DSY = 60°, and thus < BSX + < BSY = 180° - < DSY = 180° - 60° = 120°. Hence, there exists an angle t such that < BSX = 60° - t and < BSY = 60° + t (this angle t can be positive or negative or 0°).
By Lemma 1, we thus have
$\sin\measuredangle BSX+\sin\measuredangle BSY=\sin\left( 60^{\circ}-t\right)+\sin\left( 60^{\circ}+t\right) \leq2\sin60^{\circ}=2\sin\measuredangle SBR$
(since < SBR = 60°). Hence,
$2r\sin\measuredangle BSX+2r\sin\measuredangle BSY\leq2\cdot2r\sin \measuredangle SBR$,
or, in other words, $BX+BY\leq2\cdot SR$.
Since the triangle BAD is equilateral, we have < ADB = 60°, what, combined with < RDS = 60°, yields < RDS = < ADB, so that < RDB = < RDS - < SDB = < ADB - < SDB = < SDA. In other words, < YDB = < SDA. Since we also have BD = AD (this is again because the triangle BAD is equilateral) and DY = DS, it follows that the triangles YDB and SDA are congruent, and thus BY = AS. Similarly, BX = CR. Thus, the inequality $BX+BY\leq2\cdot SR$ rewrites as $CR+AS\leq2\cdot SR$. In other words, we have $2\cdot SR\geq AS+CR$. Thus,
$SR\geq\frac{AS+CR}{2}$.
But by the AM-GM inequality, $\frac{AS+CR}{2}\geq\sqrt{AS\cdot CR}$. Hence, $SR\geq\sqrt{AS\cdot CR}$, and $SR^2\geq AS\cdot CR$. And we are done.
Equality holds if and only if < BSD = 120°. The proof is left to the reader (hint: < BSD = 120° is equivalent to t = 0° and to AS = CR = SR).
Funny! I used EXACTLY the same construction!!
I found it in a very short time, not even 10 minutes, but it might not be that obvious if you don't see it immediately. Do you think this is a hard problem Darij?
Well, I don't know, but it took me way longer. Maybe it's easier to give a straightforward sine law solution which does not show the stronger inequality $SR\geq\frac{AS+CR}{2}$. Anyway, it was more than half a year ago when we - Myth and me - were solving the problem, and Myth was pretty busy while I was not too experienced with geometric inequalities. Still I find it quite a difficult problem.
darij
My write-up of the solution was much shorter.
I assumed that $DR \geq DS$. Pick points $R'$ and $S'$ on $BS$ and $DR$ respectively such that triangles $BRR'$ and $DSS'$ are equilateral. It is easy to see, by for example spiral similarity, that $CR = DR'$ and $AS = BS'$. Also, $DSR'R$ and $BRS'S$ are cyclic. So, we need to prove $\frac{SR}{DR'}\frac{SR}{BS'} \geq 1$, or $\frac{\sin 60}{\sin \alpha}\frac{\sin 60}{\sin \beta} \geq 1$, where $\alpha = \angle{S'RR'}$ and $\beta = \angle{R'SS'}$ and $\alpha + \beta = 120$. But that is obvious from Jensen, for example.