Let $k$ be a positive integer. The little one and the magician on the skywalk play a game. Initially, there are $N = 2^k$ distinct balls line up in a row, with each of the ball covered by a cup. On each turn, the little one chooses two cups, then the magician can either swap the balls in the two cups, or do a fake move so that the balls in the two cups stay the same. The little one cannot distinguish whether the magician fakes a move on not, nor can she observe the balls inside the cups. After $M = k \times 2^{k-1}$ turns, the magician opens all cups so the little one can check the ball in each of the cups. If the little one can identify whether the magician fakes a move or not for each of the $M$ turns, then the little one win. Prove that the little one has a winning strategy. Proposed by usjl
Problem
Source: 2024 Taiwan TST Round 2 Independent Study 2-C
Tags: Taiwan, combinatorics
28.03.2024 21:57
I think there's a typo and we have $N = 2^k$. Can this be confirmed? Otherwise the problem seems wrong, since one definitely requires $2^M \leq N!$.
29.03.2024 05:20
starchan wrote: I think there's a typo and we have $N = 2^k$. Can this be confirmed? Otherwise the problem seems wrong, since one definitely requires $2^M \leq N!$. It is indeed a typo. Thank you.
30.03.2024 11:37
nice problem, albeit standard-ish
30.03.2024 14:31
A non explicit strategy would be to let it be be $f(N)$ moves.And split it into two groups of $N/2$ and do $N/2$ moves pairing memebers of the first group with the second and do $f(N/2)$ moves on each group,which gives the desired $f$.