Fourteen friends met at a party. One of them, Fredek, wanted to go to bed early. He said goodbye to 10 of his friends, forgot about the remaining 3, and went to bed. After a while he returned to the party, said goodbye to 10 of his friends (not necessarily the same as before), and went to bed. Later Fredek came back a number of times, each time saying goodbye to exactly 10 of his friends, and then went back to bed. As soon as he had said goodbye to each of his friends at least once, he did not come back again. In the morning Fredek realized that he had said goodbye a different number of times to each of his thirteen friends! What is the smallest possible number of times that Fredek returned to the party?
Problem
Source: Baltic Way 2000 Problem 8
Tags: combinatorics unsolved, combinatorics
13.02.2009 17:53
Define $ g_i$ as the amount of goodbye received by friend $ i$, WLOG $ g_1 < g_2 < \cdots < g_{13}$ And $ k$ the number of times of Frederiks salutes. $ 10k=\sum_{i=1}^{13}{g_i}$ $ g_{13} \le k$ then $ 10k \le (g_{13}-12)+(g_{13}-11)+\cdots+(g_{13}-1)+g_{13}$ $ \le (k-12)+(k-11)+\cdots+(k-1)+k$ $ 0 \le 13k-78-10k$ $ 26 \le k$ and for the case $ k=26$ it is not difficult to find an example.
15.10.2019 13:23
mszew wrote: ...and for the case $ k=26$ it is not difficult to find an example. That's what happens when you don't sit down and actually write down an example. Your argument until here is correct but not sharp. In fact only $k \ge 33$ is possible (and one can actually construct an example for $k=33$!). The point is that you forgot about the special rĂ´le of the last friend to whom he only said goodbye in the last night i.e. only once! So you actually get $g_1=1$ and hence \[10k \le k+(k-1)+(k-2)+\dots+(k-11)+1=12k-65\]so that $k \ge 33$.
08.05.2020 21:32
easy problem