Problem

Source: Iranian National Olympiad (3rd Round) 2007

Tags: ratio, geometry proposed, geometry



We call a set $ A$ a good set if it has the following properties: 1. $ A$ consists circles in plane. 2. No two element of $ A$ intersect. Let $ A,B$ be two good sets. We say $ A,B$ are equivalent if we can reach from $ A$ to $ B$ by moving circles in $ A$, making them bigger or smaller in such a way that during these operations each circle does not intersect with other circles. Let $ a_{n}$ be the number of inequivalent good subsets with $ n$ elements. For example $ a_{1}= 1,a_{2}= 2,a_{3}= 4,a_{4}= 9$. If there exist $ a,b$ such that $ Aa^{n}\leq a_{n}\leq Bb^{n}$, we say growth ratio of $ a_{n}$ is larger than $ a$ and is smaller than $ b$. a) Prove that growth ratio of $ a_{n}$ is larger than 2 and is smaller than 4. b) Find better bounds for upper and lower growth ratio of $ a_{n}$.