Find out the maximum value of the numbers of edges of a solid regular octahedron that we can see from a point out of the regular octahedron.(We define we can see an edge $AB$ of the regular octahedron from point $P$ outside if and only if the intersection of non degenerate triangle $PAB$ and the solid regular octahedron is exactly edge $AB$.
Problem
Source: 2017 China TSTST Day 1 Problem 1
Tags: geometry, Tstst, solid geometry, 3D geometry, octahedron
07.03.2017 18:49
Looks fun, I'll try to sove this. I think there is a small typo though: First it says $P$ but then it says $C$.
07.03.2017 19:20
It should be $\triangle PAB$.
07.03.2017 19:47
Whoops :/
07.03.2017 20:39
I think the proof is not correct, as we can get 9 visible edges by taking a vantage point above the center of one of the faces like shown here: http://www.kjmaclean.com/Geometry/Octahedron.html
08.03.2017 04:15
fattypiggy123 wrote: It should be $\triangle PAB$. Thanks a lot.Already corrected.
08.03.2017 11:09
You can only see all three sides of a face iff the perspective and the octahedron are on different sides of the plane defined by the face. Hence, we cannot see two faces opposite each other, and if we can see an edge then we must see one of the faces containing it. If we manage to see 10 edges, then one face from each opposite pair must contain one of the hidden edges. But checking, the two hidden edges must be adjacent to a common edge, contradiction.
08.06.2017 17:13
Here is an algebraic approach to this problem:
Also, can someone tell if there exist an approach using coloring? Thank you!