Let $I_a$ be the $A$-excenter of a scalene triangle $ABC$. And let $M$ be the point symmetric to $I_a$ about line $BC$. Prove that line $AM$ is parallel to the line through the circumcenter and the orthocenter of triangle $I_aCB$.
Problem
Source: Germany 2016 - Problem 3
Tags: geometry, circumcircle, excenter, parallel, orthocenter
19.06.2016 21:28
This was the most difficult problem at this year's German olympiad, only $16 \%$ of the marks were given to all students. I find that kind of weird, I did not qualify but did find this problem rather easy. #toodifficulttoqualifyinbavaria
19.06.2016 22:19
lemma let $P,Q$ isogonal conjugates WRT the triangle $ABC $ , $\cal{C,C}$$_1,\cal{C}$$_2$ the circumcircles of $ABC,PBC,QBC$ resp. if $P',Q'$ are points of $\cal{C}$$_1,\cal{C}$$_2$ resp.such that $A-P-P'$ are collinear and $A-Q-Q'$ are collinear then $PQ\parallel P'Q'$ .we have previously prove it . back to the problem just take $ P=$ the circumcenter of $I_aBC$ which is the midpoint of arc $\overarc{BC}$ of $\cal{C}$ , $P'=A ,Q=$ the orthocenter of $I_aBC$ which is the symmetric of $I$ wrt the midpoint of $BC$ so $P,Q$ are isogonal wrt $I_aBC$ and $QBCM$ is cyclic then consider $Q'=M$ and applying the lemma yields the result. R HAS
28.05.2018 10:39
I guess Barycentric coordinates work for this problem.
28.05.2018 11:58
[asy][asy]size(7.5cm); pair A=(2,9),B=(0,0),C=(10,0),I,K,D,Dp,Ia,O,H,M,P; I=incenter(A,B,C);K=(B+C)/2;D=foot(I,B,C);Dp=2*K-D; O=extension(A,I,K,bisectorpoint(B,C));Ia=2*O-I; H=B+C-I;M=2*Dp-Ia;P=2*I-D; draw(circumcircle(A,B,C)^^circumcircle(Ia,B,C),green);draw(circle(I,abs(I-D)),orange); D(MP("A",A,N)--MP("B",B,S)--MP("D",D,S)--MP("K",K,S)--MP("D' ",Dp,SE)--MP("C",C,S)--A); D(A--MP("I",I,NE)--MP("O",O,SW)--MP("I_a",Ia,S)--MP("H",H,E)--MP("M",M,NE)--A,magenta); D(A--MP("P",P,E)--Dp,magenta);draw(P--I--D^^I--H--B--I--C--H--O^^B--Ia--C,magenta); dot(A^^B^^C^^I^^K^^D^^Dp^^O^^Ia^^H^^M^^P); [/asy][/asy] This is basically three well-known configurations tied together: Fact 5: In $\triangle ABC$, the midpoint of the arc $BC$ not containing $A$ is the center of $\odot (IBCI_a)$. Diameter of Incircle Lemma: In $\triangle ABC$, $A$, the antipode of the intouch point on $BC$ (wrt incircle) and the extouch point on $BC$ are collinear. Orthocenter-Parallelogram Lemma: (I made that name up) In $\triangle ABC$ with orthocenter $H$, and $A$'s antipode $A'$, $BHCA'$ is a parallelogram. In the main problem, let $O,H$ be the circumcenter and orthocenter of $I_aBC$ respectively. In $\triangle ABC$ let $D,D'$ be the in- and extouch point on $BC$ respectively, $K$ the midpoint of $BC$, $I$ the incenter. By Fact 5, $O$ is the midpoint of arc $BC$ and the midpoint of $II_a$. Also if $P$ is the antipode of $D$ in $\odot (I)$, we have $IK||PD'$, so by the Diameter of Incircle Lemma, $IK||AD$. Finally by the Orthocenter-Parallelogram Lemma applied to $I_aBC$, $H,K,I$ are collinear, so $IH||AD$. Now that all the pieces are together, we simply note that $$IH||AD\implies \frac{I_aI}{I_aA}=\frac{I_aH}{I_aD}\implies \frac{2I_aO}{I_aA}=\frac{I_aH}{\frac12 I_aM}\implies \frac{I_aO}{I_aA}=\frac{I_aH}{I_aM}\implies AM||OH$$And this gets the job done. $\blacksquare$
28.05.2018 13:15
What program do you use to draw ? It's so nice.
28.05.2018 13:36
That is Asymptote
29.05.2018 21:29
The result follows from a result I found sometime ago. Let $ABC$ be a triangle. A triangle $DBC$ is completed which is similar to the orthic triangle $H_aH_bH_c$ and oriented similarly. Prove that the reflection of $AD$ in $BC$ is parallel to the Euler line of $ABC.$ Proof : Let the reflection of $ A$ in $BC$ be $A'.$ Let the orthocenter and circumcenter of $A'BC$ be $H,O$ resp. Then the circles $(BHC), (BOC)$ are conjugates under the $\sqrt{bc}$ inversion and flip in $A'BC$. So the reflection of $A$ in $BC$, i.e.$ A'$, is the image of $O$, and the point $D$ is the image of $H$. So we know that $OH$ and $AD$ are parallel, and this completes the proof.
29.05.2018 21:41
Hmmm.. this problem was taken from Romania JBMO TST 2011(i found this on my RMC 2011 booklet)How this problem is so beautiful if it is taken from PREVIOUS TST?
29.05.2018 22:52
Kezer wrote: This was the most difficult problem at this year's German olympiad, only $16 \%$ of the marks were given to all students. I find that kind of weird, I did not qualify but did find this problem rather easy. #toodifficulttoqualifyinbavaria How many rounds are there? Which one was it? I guess half-final? After reading a status of Kezer it must have been a final.
30.05.2018 00:33
^There are four rounds and this is indeed the final round.
30.05.2018 06:35
Kezer wrote: Let $I_a$ be the $A$-excenter of a scalene triangle $ABC$. And let $M$ be the point symmetric to $I_a$ about line $BC$. Prove that line $AM$ is parallel to the line through the circumcenter and the orthocenter of triangle $I_aCB$. Let $H$ be the orthocenter and $O$ be the circumcenter of triangle $I_aCB$. Note that $\angle BAC=180^{\circ}-2\angle BI_aC$ hence $B,O,C,A$ are concyclic. Also $\angle AOC=\angle ABC=180^{\circ}-2\angle I_aBC$ hence $A$ lies on $I_aO$. Invert about circle with center $I_a$ and radius $\sqrt{I_aB \cdot I_aC}$ followed by reflection in bisector of angle $BI_aC$. Then $H \mapsto A$ and $O \mapsto M$ hence $HO \parallel AM$ as desired.
30.05.2018 11:00
Dear Mathlinkers, this problem is in relation with the proof concerning the incenter of the Fuhrmann's triangle. http://jl.ayme.pagesperso-orange.fr/Docs/L'orthocentre%20du%20triangle%20de%20Fuhrmann.pdf p. 11 Ayme J.-L., Revistaoim (Spain) 23 (2006) ; http://www.oei.es/historico/oim/revistaoim/numero23.htm which nead a simple adaptation... Sincerely Jean-Louis
30.05.2018 22:52
$r$ - radius of excircle, $O$ - center of circle circumscribed on triangle $BCI_a$, $H$ - orthocenter of this triangle. Easy to proof, that $ABOC$ is a quadrilateral inscribed in a circle, and by definition of $O$ we have $BO=CO$, so points $A,O,I_a$ lie on one line in this order. By law of sines $I_aO=\frac{a}{2\cos(A/2)}$. Easy trigonometry (from definition) gives $AI_a=\frac{r}{\sin(A/2)}$. $I_aM=2r, I_aH=\sqrt{4I_aO^2-a^2}=a\tan(A/2)$. $\frac{I_aO}{AI_a}=\frac{a}{r}\cdot\tan(A/2)=\frac{I_aH}{I_aM}$ hence by Tales we have $OH||AM$
25.10.2018 21:54
25.10.2018 22:44
Overkill: Note that $A$ lies on the neuberg cubic of $\triangle I_aBC$ so that's it.
26.10.2018 02:49
Fumiko wrote: Overkill: Note that $A$ lies on the neuberg cubic of $\triangle I_aBC$ Why ?
26.10.2018 10:42
TinaSprout wrote: Fumiko wrote: Overkill: Note that $A$ lies on the neuberg cubic of $\triangle I_aBC$ Why ? It is well known that if $P$ lies on the neuberg cubic of $\triangle ABC$ then $A$ lies on the neuberg cubic of $\triangle BPC$ .
26.10.2018 16:37
Looking at the problem from the perspective of triangle $I_ABC$ leads to an almost immediate solution: it's easy to show that $\sqrt{bc}$ inversion swaps $O$ and $M$, and $H$ and $A$. Then $I_AH \cdot I_AA = I_AO \cdot I_AM$, so we are done by similar triangles.
28.12.2018 19:35
Here’s my solution [asy][asy]size(10cm); pair A=(2,9),B=(0,0),C=(10,0),I,K,D,Dp,Ia,O,H,M,P; I=incenter(A,B,C);K=(B+C)/2;D=foot(I,B,C);Dp=2*K-D; O=extension(A,I,K,bisectorpoint(B,C));Ia=2*O-I; H=B+C-I;M=2*Dp-Ia;P=2*I-D; draw(circumcircle(A,B,C),orange); D(MP("A",A,N)--MP("B",B,S)--MP("D",D,S)--MP("K",K,S)--MP("D' ",Dp,SE)--MP("C",C,S)--A); D(A--MP("I",I,NE)--MP("O",O,SW)--MP("I_a",Ia,S)--MP("H",H,E)--MP("M",M,NE)--A,heavygreen); D(A--MP("P",P,E)--Dp,heavygreen);draw(P--I--D^^I--H--B--I--C--H--O^^B--Ia--C,red); dot(A^^B^^C^^I^^K^^D^^Dp^^O^^Ia^^H^^M^^P); [/asy][/asy] It is well known that $IKH \parallel AD’$. So, by comparing ratios, we have $\frac{I_aI}{2I_aA} = \frac{I_aO}{I_aA} = \frac{I_aH}{2I_aD’} = \frac{I_aH}{I_aM}$. Thus $\boxed{AM \parallel OH}$. $\blacksquare$.
20.08.2020 12:31
Denote $O,H$ respectively as circumcenter and orthocenter of the triangle $BCI_A$. Let $a,b,c$ be complex numbers lying on unit circle such that $a^2,b^2,c^2$ are vertices of the triangle and $-(ab+bc+ca)$ is the incenter. Then $$e_A=ab-bc+ca,\ o=-bc,\ h=b^2+c^2+ab+bc+ca.$$Last equation can be obtained without complex bashing by observing that $BICH$ is a parallelogram. Reflection formula yields $$m=b^2+c^2-b^2c^2\cdot \overline{e_A}=b^2+c^2+\frac{a-b-c}{a}\cdot bc.$$Finally $$a^2-m=a^2-b^2-c^2+\frac{-a+b+c}{a}\cdot bc=\frac{(a-b)(a-c)(a+b+c)}{a}$$and $$h-o=(b+c+a)(b+c).$$If $a+b+c=0$ we have $a^2-m=h-o$ implying $AM\parallel HO$. If $a+b+c=0\neq 0$ $$\frac{a^2-m}{h-o}=\frac{(a-b)(a-c)}{a(b+c)}=\overline{\left(\frac{a^2-m}{h-o}\right)}.\square$$#1710
21.08.2020 00:28
Here are two solutions which I found just now by just gazing at the diagram in #21. Kezer wrote: Let $I_a$ be the $A$-excenter of a scalene triangle $ABC$. And let $M$ be the point symmetric to $I_a$ about line $BC$. Prove that line $AM$ is parallel to the line through the circumcenter and the orthocenter of triangle $I_aCB$. [asy][asy]size(10cm); pair A=(2,9),B=(0,0),C=(10,0),I,K,D,Dp,Ia,O,H,M,P; I=incenter(A,B,C);K=(B+C)/2;D=foot(I,B,C);Dp=2*K-D; O=extension(A,I,K,bisectorpoint(B,C));Ia=2*O-I; H=B+C-I;M=2*Dp-Ia;P=2*I-D; draw(circumcircle(A,B,C),orange); D(MP("A",A,N)--MP("B",B,S)--MP("D",D,S)--MP("K",K,S)--MP("D' ",Dp,SE)--MP("C",C,S)--A); D(A--MP("I",I,NE)--MP("O",O,SW)--MP("I_a",Ia,S)--MP("H",H,E)--MP("M",M,NE)--A,heavygreen); D(A--MP("P",P,E)--Dp,heavygreen);draw(P--I--D^^I--H--B--I--C--H--O^^B--Ia--C,red); dot(A^^B^^C^^I^^K^^D^^Dp^^O^^Ia^^H^^M^^P); [/asy][/asy] \begin{align*} \textbf{First Solution:-} \end{align*} $\measuredangle CI_aH=\measuredangle AI_aB$ and $\measuredangle HCI_a=\measuredangle BAI_a\implies\Delta I_aHV\stackrel{+}{\sim}\Delta I_aBA\implies I_aH\cdot I_aA=I_aB\cdot I_aC$. So, $\sqrt{I_aB\cdot I_aC}$ Inversion around $I_a$ followed by a reflection around the angle bisector of $\angle BI_aC$ swaps $\{O,M\}$ and $\{H,A\}$. So, $\overline{OH}\|\overline{AM}$. $\blacksquare$ \begin{align*} \textbf{Second Solution:-} \end{align*} Notice that $\{A,M\}$ are pairs of Isogonal Conjugates WRT $\Delta BI_aC$ also $A$ lies on the Neuberg Cubic of $\Delta BI_aC$. So, $\overline{AM}\|\overline{OH}$ as Neuberg Cubic has its pivot at $\infty_{\overline{OH}}$. $\blacksquare$
15.04.2023 16:21
We use complex numbers and set $(ABC)$ as the unit circle. Let the coordinates of $A$, $B$ and $C$ be $a^2$, $b^2$ and $c^2$ so that the incenter $J$ is given by $j=-ab-bc-ca$. It is well-known that the excenter $I_a$ is given by $j_a=ab+ca-bc$ so that the coordinates of $O$, the circumcenter of $I_ABC$ is given by $o=\frac12(j+j_a)=bc$ as it is the midpoint of $II_A$ by the incenter excenter lemma. Then we calculate \[m=\frac{(b-c)(\overline{ab+ca-bc})+\overline{b}c-b\overline{c}}{\overline{b}-\overline{c}}=\frac{(b-c)(\frac{1}{ab}+\frac{1}{ca}-\frac{1}{bc})+\frac{c}{b}-\frac{b}{c}}{\frac{1}{b}-\frac{1}{c}}\]As $OH$ is the Euler-line of $I_ABC$, we know that its centroid $s=\frac{j_a+b+c}{3}=\frac{ab+ca-bc+b+c}{3}$ also lies on that line. Therefore, it suffices to show that the points $m-a^2$ and $s-o$ are collinear with the orgin, meaning the ratio \[\left(\frac{m-a^2}{s-o}\right)\]should be real. From here on it is just straight calculation.